Storage devices - Flash drives vs HD

Post new topic   Reply to topic

View previous topic View next topic Go down

Storage devices - Flash drives vs HD

Post  CN on Thu Sep 11, 2008 11:06 am

Today (September 11th) there is a great article on the Tom's Hardware about this topic. If you want to read the full article the link is http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/usb-hard-drive,2015.html
I'll try to make it more simple.
On this article the team trys to compare the speed between a USB 2.0 Flash drive and an ATA/33 Hard Drive from IBM. They got this because the size (the flash drive has 8GB and the HD has 10.1GB). Reading the article, you will see that is not the best test once the HD has over 10 years and the flash drive is new. However it's amazing how it goes. Let me cut to the chase and tell what is important...
Here is the conclusion:
"Admittedly, this comparison is not relevant to everyday life, but it is still interesting as a thought experiment, as the outcome was all but predictable. Forgive us for comparing an ultra-portable, compact USB storage device with a 10-year old ATA/33 desktop hard drive, but when we took stock of our hardware, we found ourselves looking at these two physically and architecturally different pieces of storage technology that still had important details in common. The IBM DTTA-351010 10 GB hard drive and the Super Talent Pico C 8 GB USB flash drive offer similar capacities and similar interface throughput. And we found the size and weight difference simply amazing.

On the one hand, it was obvious that any decent flash-based storage device can deliver far better transfer rates than a 10-year old hard drive: 12.4 MB/s maximum transfer rates are awful, and the Pico C flash driveflash drive clearly earns a victory here.

However, we found it shocking to see the difference in I/O performance. Super Talent’s flash drive would perform amazingly well as long as write operations were left out of the equation. But as soon as write operations were involved, the old hard drive would still beat the modern flash drive by a considerable margin.

Our results make clear that products such as the Super Talent Pico C 8 GB USB thumb drives should be used as storage devices for occasional use, and preferably for large files such as photo, audio or video files. They are by no means capable of replacing hard drive when I/O intensive workload is requested, because performance in this task will be disappointing. Should you be looking for a low-capacity drive for a low-power PC, we recommend looking around for other solutions that deliver better performance."


That's it for now...

CN
Administrador

Number of posts: 18
Registration date: 2008-07-16

View user profile

Back to top Go down

View previous topic View next topic Back to top


Post new topic   Reply to topic
Permissions of this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum